Marnach 16th December 1944

Forum rules
Blog only links will be removed, please post a few sample pics within the thread

Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby Richard B. » 09 Jan 2018

Manarch
Ardennes, December 16/17th 1944

Way back in my teens I came home from school to find my Dad had thrown out my entire collection! Hundreds of plastic figures (metals being far too expensive for me back then) and dozens of plastic kits and di-cast models, to say the least I was devastated. This of course put an end to my wargaming hobby until in my early twenties, whilst working in Cardiff I wandered into a games shop and saw "Bastogne", an A4 campaign booklet for Command Decision rules by Frank Chadwick and Greg Novak. The booklet had some colour and B/W images of 20mm models and soldiers, painted and set-up for battle; this brought back memories of the illustrations in the books by Charles Grant, Terrance Wise and Don Featherstone; this one chance discovery drew me back into models and eventually wargaming.

For the first few years my hobby fixated on Bastogne and the Ardennes offensive almost exclusively, the desperate fighting in the mud and snow between German and American units of varied abilities has much to attract the wargamer who likes challenging games yet doesn`t want the Allied air superiority to dominate the battlefield. Part of the battle which fascinated me most was the first few days where US infantry, surprised and outnumbered, managed to hold back the might of 5th Panzer Armee, just long enough for SHAEF to scrabble its reserves forward to bolster the line. Without the dogged defence and sacrifice made by these men (long overlooked) 5th Panzer Armee may well have reached Bastogne before the 101st airborne and the outcome of the battle changed dramatically.

Now many years later I find myself with a big collection and a wargames room in Spain with a permanent 8x4` table. My lads and I try and have a game whenever we are there for more than a week, so for Christmas 2017, I decided to revisit old ground

History
The 28th Division held the southern half of VIII Corp`s front. The three regiments were deployed along its frontage: the 109th in the south, 110th in the centre and the 112th in the north. The 110th Regiment (Col. Hurley Fuller) was actually responsible for about half of the divisions total frontage! The 110th also had to make do with only two of its three battalions on the line, as the third had been taken by division and held in reserve! The Regiment`s only option was to hold a series of isolated strong-points, blocking roads for any enemy advance. These were supplemented by active patrolling during daylight and advanced listening posts overlooking the Our River.

On the German side General von Luttwitz`s 47th Panzer Corps was tasked with seizing crossing points over the Our River and capturing the strategic road junction of Bastogne, then moving onto the Meuse. The frontage for his initial plan with two divisions corresponded almost exactly to the defensive frontage of the 110th Infantry!

The game
Taking advantage of our larger table in Spain I have decided to run this historically based game, set during the first few days of the Ardennes offensive. Concentrating solely on the battles and area concerning the I (and later II) battalions of the US 110th Infantry Regiment. The game offers an interesting challenge with the Germans having to move across difficult terrain against an entrenched alert enemy.

The game starts at 0800 some two hours after some intense artillery, mortar and rocket fire has smashed down across the 110th strong-points. All I Battalion positions were hit - Heinerscheid ("A" Company), Grindhausen ("D" Company)- both north, off table as far as our game is concerned north and Marnach ("B" Company), Munshausen ("C" Company) and Reuler (Battery "B" 109th Field artillery). This barrage not just caused casualties and damage but cut all the telephone wires leading between positions and back to the rear, effectively cutting off each unit from both Battalion and Regiment plus one-another! The barrage lifted after about 30 minutes, but additional short salvos persisted over the next couple of hours.

In the early hours of December 16th 2nd Panzer Division began sending its panzergrenadiers across the Our. After struggling up the steep valley sides through thick under-growth and trees and a minefield they finally arrived at their jump-off points for their first objective - Marnach, the time was 0800.


German orders
2nd Panzergrenadiers are spearheading the attack, your orders are to seize Marnach and open the roads to the Clerve River bridges ahead of the armoured and mobile elements; awaiting completion of engineer build bridges over the Our river to the East.
The weather is cold and wet with low lying fog, the terrain rough and very wet, all this has combined to delay the progress of your lead units, but finally you are in position to attack.

Use combined infiltration and direct assault tactics to achieve your objectives.

US orders
Your Battalion holds a series of company sized forward outposts along the ridge overlooking the Our River (the German frontline). Your orders are to set listening and observation posts during the day supplemented by combat patrols. These have a two-fold purpose: 1. Standard frontline field practice. 2. Training and acclimatising of new and green replacements into the companies, platoons and sections.

Your Division has been assigned to this quite sector of the front to recover and refit from the mauling it took during the battles for the Hurtgen Forest region. Many of your soldiers are fresh replacements and those remaining veterans are worn to a thread.

At about 0530 this morning all your frontline outposts were hit by quite heavy artillery, rocket and mortar salvoes. Virtually at once all communications to the rear and other outposts ceased as the shell fire cut telephone cables; you are on your own!

You decided to stand your men on alert and the Germans continued to shell your positions on and off over the next few hours, between shelling the sounds of heavy vehicle traffic drifts across the valley from the east (the German side).

About thirty minutes ago your scouts reported hearing men moving up through the wooded hillside towards the road which runs along ridge (known as Skyline Drive), this is it......


US initial dispositions and OOB, 16th December 1944

Marnach
"B" Coy 110th Infnatry + spotter for Battery "B" 109th Field Artillery

Recce platoon "B" Company, 630th Tank Destroyer Battalion
Gun section (towed 3"), 630th Tank Destroyer Battalion

Munshausen
"C" Coy 110th Infantry
Cannon Coy 110th Infantry

Reuler
"B" Battery 109th Field Artillery
Platoon, Battery "B" 447th AAA AW Battalion (Mobile)

Reinforcements:
Arrive Munshausen 1100hrs 16/12
2 platoons M4 tanks (707th Tank Battalion)

From Clervaux 0600 December 17th
"E" & "F" Coys 110th Infantry
Elements "H" Coy 110th Infantry:
2 x .30cal MMG teams + truck
2 x 81mm mortar teams (can be directed by either infantry company HQs) + truck
1 x 57mm AT gun with crew + tow
M4 Sherman company (707th Tank Battalion)
platoon of M18 tank destroyers (630th Tank Destroyer Battalion)

German Forces

Initial units:
Enter from the east (Our River) 0800hrs 16/12
I Battalion, 2nd Panzergrenadier Regiment (dismounted less weapons company) with:

Support:
II Battalion, 74th Artillery Regiment

Reinforcements @ 1000hrs 16/12
II Battalion 2nd Panzergrenadier Regiment (dismounted less weapon company)
As I battalion above

2 companies 2nd Panzer Auflarungs Abteilung (dismounted) each with:

1700hrs 16/12
Elements II Battalion, 3rd Panzer Regiment


1900hrs 16/12
Transport and support elements I Battalion, 2nd Panzergrenadier Regiment

Our table
Left side with Munshausen in the background
Image
Marnach in the centre with Reuler behind
Image
Munshausen with the Cannon Companies position
Image
Reuler with "B" battery 109th FA
Image
Munshausen looking toward Marnach
Image
Marnach
Image
German Battalion HQ
Image
US infantry company support weapon platoon
Image

The initial moves saw the German 1st Battalion or 2nd Panzergrenadier Regiment (2nd panzer) advancing slowly towards the US positions. My dispositions in attack was 1st Kompanie reinforced with a pioneer platoon would attack Marnach head-on with 2nd Kompanie on their right (north) with orders to advance to the road then pinch in and envelope the town. 3rd Kompanie on the left (south) was to move up to the road and cut it preventing US forces from moving reinforcements into the town. Both 2nd & 3rd Kompanies bolstered by a Panzershreck team.
Image
Image
Image
Meanwhile "B" Company 110th awaited their arrival.
Image
Image
Image
"C" Company at Munshausen
Image
Image

1st Kompanie and the pioneers walked into a world of hurt! They barely got off the start line before moral sapping casualties occurred. Their left most platoon, eventually joined 2nd Kompanie as it moved out of the line of fire. Though the CP did bring in some directed artillery fire causing some US casualties.
2nd Kompanie had more luck with one of its platoons stumbling onto a weak point in the US defensive plan, this was quickly exploited by a second platoon supported by the arrival of the survivors from 1st Kompanie; this caused the Yanks to fall back across the highway..
Image
Image
Image
3rd Kompanie totally achieved its objectives though it did take casualties from directed artillery fire.
Image
Image

By 9.30am (turn15) 2nd Kompanie`s CP crossed the highway and advanced to the crest of the ridge along with one platoon cleared the ridge and began bringing directed fire onto Battery "B" in Reuler; who almost immediately bugged out.............
The rest of 2nd Kompanie plus the survivors of 1st Kompanie moved into the town, fighting house to house against the defenders.
By 10am (turn 20) the Yanks held just one house and with the German 2nd Battalion about to arrive, we called it quits.
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image

Tough if not impossible task for the Americans to hold Marnach, the boys agreed that without artillery support there was no chance of the remaining "B" Company guys holding off a new fresh battalion long enough for the 707th tanks to arrive at Munshausen at 11am. But one US company had effectively destroyed a German one and blooded two others in the process. Historically when the tanks drove from Munshausen to Marnach on the afternoon of December 16th, they found no evidence that "B" Company was still there and the place was full of Germans.........
Richard B.
Scaramanga
 
Posts: 6753
Medals: 54
Capt Campaigner (1) Cav Campaigner (1) Comm Campaigner (1) Sur1 campaigner (1) Afloat Campaigner (1) England Campaigner (1)
Flak Campaigner (1) Building Campaigner (1) Comms Campaigner (1) Photo 2nd place (1) FriendFoe Campaigner (1) Armour Campaigner (1)
Terrain2 Campaigner (1) Portrait Campaigner (1) fortified campaigner (1) Recce campaigner (1) Engineer campaigner (1) Leader Campaigner (1)
Casualty Campaigner (1) Female Campaigner (1) Sniper Campaigner (1) Winter Campaigner (1) 40mm Campaigner (1) Wings Campaigner (1)
POW Campaigner (1) Truck Campaigner (1) 30mm 3rd place (1) Red Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1) AntiTank Campaigner (1)
Easter14 Campaigner (1) Ambulance campaigner (1) 60mm campaigner (1) dday campaigner (1) quick campaigner (1) Lib Minis Campaigner (1)
Terrain Campaigner (1) Brit Minis Campaigner (1) Plast1 Campaigner (1) Battle Campaigner (1) SandS Campaigner (1) Pendraken Campaigner (1)
Battlegroup Campaigner (1) Scen1 Campaigner (1) 2010 Build (1) 2011 Build (1) 2012 Build (1) 2013 Build (1)
xmas15 campaigner (1) xmas14 campaigner (1) 2014 build (1) 2015 build campaigner (1) 50 builds (1) 2016 build campaigner (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby mausmann » 09 Jan 2018

Absolutely top notch table, AAR and game mate! Great to see you back too.... :clapping: :clapping: :clapping: :clapping:
Greatness lies not in where we stand, but in what direction we are moving. We must sail sometimes with the wind, and sometimes against it, but sail we must, and not drift nor lie at anchor.
User avatar
mausmann
Renard
 
Posts: 15586
Medals: 29
Capt Campaigner (1) Comm Campaigner (1) Sur1 3rd place (1) Afloat Campaigner (1) Flak Campaigner (1) Armour 1st place (1)
fortified 1st place (1) Recce 3rd place (1) Leader Campaigner (1) Casualty Campaigner (1) Female Campaigner (1) Sniper Campaigner (1)
40mm Campaigner (1) Wings Campaigner (1) 30mm Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1) Easter14 Campaigner (1) Ambulance campaigner (1)
dday 1st place (1) Terrain Campaigner (1) Brit Minis Campaigner (1) Battle Campaigner (1) SandS 1st place (1) Scen1 Campaigner (1)
Big Game 2010 (1) 2013 Build 1st place (1) 2014 build 1st place (1) 2015 build 1st place (1) 2016 build 1st place (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby NTM » 09 Jan 2018

Great report. :thumbsup:

Marnach is one I hope to do someday using the scenario from the Battlefront WWII rulebook.
User avatar
NTM
Largo
 
Posts: 3153
Medals: 8
30mm Campaigner (1) Red Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1) 60mm campaigner (1) 2013 Build (1) xmas15 campaigner (1)
xmas14 campaigner (1) easter15 campaigner (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby SP> » 09 Jan 2018

Bit tight of your dad... you've got a great set up now though. Cracking stuff. :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
"... and then my loneliness closes in so I drink a German wine and drift in dreams of other lives and greater times..."

http://spprojectblog.wordpress.com/

http://www.penninemegagames.co.uk/
User avatar
SP>
Blofeld
 
Posts: 4250
Medals: 37
Cav Campaigner (1) Sur1 campaigner (1) Afloat Campaigner (1) Scratch1 Campaigner (1) Flak Campaigner (1) Building Campaigner (1)
Comms Campaigner (1) Terrain2 Campaigner (1) Portrait Campaigner (1) fortified campaigner (1) Recce campaigner (1) Engineer campaigner (1)
Leader Campaigner (1) Casualty Campaigner (1) Female Campaigner (1) Sniper Campaigner (1) 40mm Campaigner (1) Wings Campaigner (1)
POW Campaigner (1) Truck Campaigner (1) 30mm Campaigner (1) Red Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1) Ambulance campaigner (1)
60mm campaigner (1) dday campaigner (1) quick campaigner (1) Terrain Campaigner (1) Brit Minis Campaigner (1) Plast1 Campaigner (1)
Battle Campaigner (1) SandS Campaigner (1) Scen1 Campaigner (1) 2010 Build (1) 2012 Build (1) xmas14 campaigner (1)
easter15 campaigner (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby Taylor » 09 Jan 2018

Great report, figs, photo's etc., a joy to read :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo:
All great things are simple, and many can be expressed in single words: freedom, justice, honor, duty, mercy, hope.
Sir Winston Churchill
User avatar
Taylor
Scaramanga
 
Posts: 6138
Medals: 35
Flak Campaigner (1) Building Campaigner (1) Comms Campaigner (1) Photo 3rd place (1) FriendFoe 3rd place (1) Armour Campaigner (1)
Terrain2 Campaigner (1) Portrait Campaigner (1) fortified 1st place (1) Recce campaigner (1) Engineer campaigner (1) 40mm Campaigner (1)
Wings Campaigner (1) POW Campaigner (1) Truck Campaigner (1) 30mm Campaigner (1) Red Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1)
AntiTank Campaigner (1) Easter14 Campaigner (1) Ambulance campaigner (1) 60mm campaigner (1) dday campaigner (1) quick campaigner (1)
SandS Campaigner (1) Pendraken Campaigner (1) Battlegroup Campaigner (1) 2012 Build (1) 2013 Build (1) xmas15 campaigner (1)
xmas14 campaigner (1) 2014 build (1) easter15 3rd place (1) 2015 build campaigner (1) 2016 build campaigner (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby Bill » 09 Jan 2018

Very nice.
User avatar
Bill
Dr No
 
Posts: 1166

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby dead1 » 11 Jan 2018

Excellent! Thank you for sharing.
dead1
Pussy Galore
 
Posts: 909
Medals: 1
2014 build (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby prussianhussaruk » 11 Jan 2018

Excellent AAR.

Thanks for posting

Don

Happy New Year.
Wargamming WWII in 20mm, THE TRUE SCALE.

Don McHugh - Long time English Rugby supporter.
User avatar
prussianhussaruk
Goldfinger
 
Posts: 2044
Medals: 14
Flak Campaigner (1) Comms Campaigner (1) Terrain2 Campaigner (1) Recce campaigner (1) Engineer campaigner (1) 40mm Campaigner (1)
Wings Campaigner (1) Red Campaigner (1) Brit Minis 1st place (1) Plast1 2nd place (1) SandS Campaigner (1) 2010 Build 2nd place (1)
2011 Build (1) 2012 Build (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby Richard B. » 11 Jan 2018

Thanks guys :thumbsup:
Richard B.
Scaramanga
 
Posts: 6753
Medals: 54
Capt Campaigner (1) Cav Campaigner (1) Comm Campaigner (1) Sur1 campaigner (1) Afloat Campaigner (1) England Campaigner (1)
Flak Campaigner (1) Building Campaigner (1) Comms Campaigner (1) Photo 2nd place (1) FriendFoe Campaigner (1) Armour Campaigner (1)
Terrain2 Campaigner (1) Portrait Campaigner (1) fortified campaigner (1) Recce campaigner (1) Engineer campaigner (1) Leader Campaigner (1)
Casualty Campaigner (1) Female Campaigner (1) Sniper Campaigner (1) Winter Campaigner (1) 40mm Campaigner (1) Wings Campaigner (1)
POW Campaigner (1) Truck Campaigner (1) 30mm 3rd place (1) Red Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1) AntiTank Campaigner (1)
Easter14 Campaigner (1) Ambulance campaigner (1) 60mm campaigner (1) dday campaigner (1) quick campaigner (1) Lib Minis Campaigner (1)
Terrain Campaigner (1) Brit Minis Campaigner (1) Plast1 Campaigner (1) Battle Campaigner (1) SandS Campaigner (1) Pendraken Campaigner (1)
Battlegroup Campaigner (1) Scen1 Campaigner (1) 2010 Build (1) 2011 Build (1) 2012 Build (1) 2013 Build (1)
xmas15 campaigner (1) xmas14 campaigner (1) 2014 build (1) 2015 build campaigner (1) 50 builds (1) 2016 build campaigner (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby 7dot62mm » 11 Jan 2018

Fantastic stuff! :yahoo: :yahoo:
User avatar
7dot62mm
Dr No
 
Posts: 1616
Medals: 14
Afloat Campaigner (1) Armour Campaigner (1) Terrain2 Campaigner (1) Recce campaigner (1) Engineer campaigner (1) Female Campaigner (1)
quick campaigner (1) Lib Minis Campaigner (1) Plast1 Campaigner (1) xmas15 campaigner (1) xmas14 campaigner (1) easter15 campaigner (1)
2015 build campaigner (1) 2016 build campaigner (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby mausmann » 11 Jan 2018

Just re-reading the orbits given, can you add what the 2 x Panzer Auflarungs Abteilung consist of?.... :thumbsup:
User avatar
mausmann
Renard
 
Posts: 15586
Medals: 29
Capt Campaigner (1) Comm Campaigner (1) Sur1 3rd place (1) Afloat Campaigner (1) Flak Campaigner (1) Armour 1st place (1)
fortified 1st place (1) Recce 3rd place (1) Leader Campaigner (1) Casualty Campaigner (1) Female Campaigner (1) Sniper Campaigner (1)
40mm Campaigner (1) Wings Campaigner (1) 30mm Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1) Easter14 Campaigner (1) Ambulance campaigner (1)
dday 1st place (1) Terrain Campaigner (1) Brit Minis Campaigner (1) Battle Campaigner (1) SandS 1st place (1) Scen1 Campaigner (1)
Big Game 2010 (1) 2013 Build 1st place (1) 2014 build 1st place (1) 2015 build 1st place (1) 2016 build 1st place (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby NTM » 11 Jan 2018

mausmann wrote:Just re-reading the orbits given, can you add what the 2 x Panzer Auflarungs Abteilung consist of?.... :thumbsup:


From Richard's blog

"2 companies 2nd Panzer Auflarungs Abteilung (dismounted) each with:

HQ: CO, RTO, NCO, runner

2 platoons off: 2 officer/NCO, 2 LMG teams, 6 SMG/Stg44"

http://baberonwargames.blogspot.co.uk/2 ... 4.html?m=1
User avatar
NTM
Largo
 
Posts: 3153
Medals: 8
30mm Campaigner (1) Red Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1) 60mm campaigner (1) 2013 Build (1) xmas15 campaigner (1)
xmas14 campaigner (1) easter15 campaigner (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby Richard B. » 11 Jan 2018

Yes (thanks Nick) as they are usually carried in Sd250s (with only a 6-figure capacity) Auflarung platoons are smaller than normal panzergrenadier or infantry plts in our simplified rules.

I also limit Auflarlung infantry companies to 2plts + HQ, which almost makes them a whole platoon weaker in actual manpower than an equivalent infantry or PG Kompanie, but firepower is slighly higher with one LMG per 6 men (rather than 1 per 10), and the late war infantry are mostly armed with STG44 or MP40 automatics.
Richard B.
Scaramanga
 
Posts: 6753
Medals: 54
Capt Campaigner (1) Cav Campaigner (1) Comm Campaigner (1) Sur1 campaigner (1) Afloat Campaigner (1) England Campaigner (1)
Flak Campaigner (1) Building Campaigner (1) Comms Campaigner (1) Photo 2nd place (1) FriendFoe Campaigner (1) Armour Campaigner (1)
Terrain2 Campaigner (1) Portrait Campaigner (1) fortified campaigner (1) Recce campaigner (1) Engineer campaigner (1) Leader Campaigner (1)
Casualty Campaigner (1) Female Campaigner (1) Sniper Campaigner (1) Winter Campaigner (1) 40mm Campaigner (1) Wings Campaigner (1)
POW Campaigner (1) Truck Campaigner (1) 30mm 3rd place (1) Red Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1) AntiTank Campaigner (1)
Easter14 Campaigner (1) Ambulance campaigner (1) 60mm campaigner (1) dday campaigner (1) quick campaigner (1) Lib Minis Campaigner (1)
Terrain Campaigner (1) Brit Minis Campaigner (1) Plast1 Campaigner (1) Battle Campaigner (1) SandS Campaigner (1) Pendraken Campaigner (1)
Battlegroup Campaigner (1) Scen1 Campaigner (1) 2010 Build (1) 2011 Build (1) 2012 Build (1) 2013 Build (1)
xmas15 campaigner (1) xmas14 campaigner (1) 2014 build (1) 2015 build campaigner (1) 50 builds (1) 2016 build campaigner (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby mausmann » 11 Jan 2018

Many thanx Nick and Richard.... :thumbsup:
User avatar
mausmann
Renard
 
Posts: 15586
Medals: 29
Capt Campaigner (1) Comm Campaigner (1) Sur1 3rd place (1) Afloat Campaigner (1) Flak Campaigner (1) Armour 1st place (1)
fortified 1st place (1) Recce 3rd place (1) Leader Campaigner (1) Casualty Campaigner (1) Female Campaigner (1) Sniper Campaigner (1)
40mm Campaigner (1) Wings Campaigner (1) 30mm Campaigner (1) Green Campaigner (1) Easter14 Campaigner (1) Ambulance campaigner (1)
dday 1st place (1) Terrain Campaigner (1) Brit Minis Campaigner (1) Battle Campaigner (1) SandS 1st place (1) Scen1 Campaigner (1)
Big Game 2010 (1) 2013 Build 1st place (1) 2014 build 1st place (1) 2015 build 1st place (1) 2016 build 1st place (1)

Re: Marnach 16th December 1944

Postby SABOT » 11 Jan 2018

Top notch.
"Keep Loading!"
User avatar
SABOT
Jaws
 
Posts: 354


Return to Game reports

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests